Comparative Market Analysis (CMA)

CMAs help determine competitive listing prices and realistic expectations.

What is a CMA?

A Comparative Market Analysis (CMA) is a comprehensive evaluation tool used in real estate to estimate a property’s market value by comparing it to similar properties that have recently sold, are currently for sale, or were listed but didn’t sell in the same area.

Purpose and Benefits

For Sellers:

• Determines competitive and realistic listing prices
• Sets proper expectations for sale timeline and final sale price
• Helps avoid overpricing (which can lead to extended time on market) or underpricing (which can result in lost equity)

For Buyers:

• Provides insight into fair market value for properties of interest
• Supports informed offer decisions
• Helps identify good value opportunities in the market

Key Components of a CMA

Comparable Properties (“Comps”)

• Recently Sold Properties: Homes that closed within the last 3-6 months
• Active Listings: Properties currently for sale in the area
• Expired/Withdrawn Listings: Properties that failed to sell, indicating potential overpricing

Property Characteristics Analyzed

• Location and neighborhood
• Square footage and lot size
• Number of bedrooms and bathrooms
• Age and condition of the property
• Architectural style and features
• Recent improvements or renovations
• Garage and parking availability

Market Conditions

• Current supply and demand trends
• Average days on market
• Price trends (increasing, stable, or declining)
• Seasonal market fluctuations
• Economic factors affecting the local market

How CMAs are Created

1. Property Research: Gathering detailed information about the subject property
2. Comparable Selection: Identifying 3-6 similar properties within a reasonable distance
3. Adjustment Analysis: Accounting for differences between the subject property and comparables
4. Market Trend Analysis: Considering current market conditions and recent changes
5. Value Range Determination: Establishing a likely price range based on all factors

Who Provides CMAs

• Real Estate Agents: Most commonly prepared by licensed agents as part of their services
• Real Estate Brokers: Senior professionals with additional market expertise
• Appraisers: Professional appraisers for more formal valuations
• Online Tools: Automated valuation models (AVMs) for preliminary estimates

When to Use a CMA

For Selling:

• Before listing your property
• When considering refinancing
• For estate planning or divorce proceedings
• When evaluating home improvement ROI

For Buying:

• Before making an offer on a property
• When negotiating price reductions
• To understand neighborhood value trends

Limitations and Considerations

• CMAs provide estimates, not definitive appraisals
• Market conditions can change rapidly
• Unique property features may be difficult to compare
• Local market knowledge and expertise significantly impact accuracy
• Should be updated regularly as market conditions evolve

Best Practices

• Use recent sales data (within 3-6 months when possible)
• Select truly comparable properties in terms of size, condition, and location
• Consider multiple data points rather than relying on a single comparable
• Factor in current market trends and conditions
• Work with experienced local real estate professionals for most accurate results

---

Note: While CMAs provide valuable market insights, they should be used in conjunction with professional real estate advice for important financial decisions.